simplify and go back to paper
I won’t tell your secrets
Your secrets are safe with me
I will keep your secrets
Just think of me as the pages in your diary
Everyone has a Luddite moment. Be honest with yourself, even you.
How many business plans have been sketched out on a napkin? Have not some of the most powerful and personal presentations you’ve ever witnessed been done on a whiteboard?
Why is that?
With all of the rumors about a new mac iTablet, the releases of Kindles, new Nooks etc. one would naturally expect that we’ll all soon be sporting communications tablets that have all of our media, our documents, our communications in one simple form factor. As long as we keep them charged up, we’ll have access to our data. As long as we back them up, and keep those backups up-to-date, we’ll have access to that ever-growing personally duplicated library of stuff forever.
Yet somehow paper and pens do not seem to go away.
Surely everyone has an electronic diary? …and surely all our diaries talk to each other and help schedules our daily lives in perfect digital harmony and sync with our other devices and personal variables and variabilities?
How many of you still jot stuff down on good old-fashioned, environmentally unfriendly paper pulp? You know, the kind that uses less power and employs the most humanly evolved stream of consciousness indexing system? The kind that if stored reasonably well, will last hundreds of years without power, and will retain that memory as it was produced and laid-out by the original author cum publisher?
How many hard drives, flash drives, CDs and DVDs will last that long? How many software packages will last that long? And more importantly, how many will be compatible with future technologies? To be a little more specific, how many of you can still read your original WordStar documents? Or those original MSMail messages? Or…? My guess is that most has been tossed away (or lost) years ago. At some point we inevitably, intentionally or accidentally, de-clutter our lives. Much like an evolutionary process for information brought about by external environmental factors.
The digital archiving dilemma ensures that we’ll be forced to keep converting our ever-increasing digital content to constantly changing new technologies. Each iteration of such new technology will consume new resources and energy to be manufactured, but to also to convert bits to new formats, only to repeat the cycle again and again. Brings a whole new meaning to recycling doesn’t it? Meanwhile, paper and film still stay the same, in the same underground limestone vaults, stored without laying claim to increased resource utilization.
Are old analog formats less convenient? Usually, they take more time to handle and search. Are they less accessible? Generally. Are they more personal or authentic? Always. Are they more secure? Generally so, because it takes more work to copy millions until they’re digitized.
And the quality, generational loss etc… perhaps it’s not worth saving giving the resources it will waste over its lifetime?
I think I’ll start investigating the comparison of archival costs for documents on paper vs. electronic for say the next 250 years. No, I do not hope to live that long…! My guess is that paper (and its analog cohorts) will still win.
Oh, and by the way, I don’t need a touch tablet to draw and write freehand. Paper works for that too.
Tell me it isn’t so… I’m listening!